A study commissioned by
Environmental Working Group (EWG) Action Fund has found that four brands of children’s crayons
and two kids’ crime scene fingerprint kits sold in the United States
contain asbestos. This report follows two previous tests performed in
2000 and 2007 which found asbestos present in some crayons and finger
printing kits. According to the labels, these products were made in China
and imported to the U.S.
The two crime scene kits were found to contain higher concentrations of
asbestos than the crayon samples. Also, the loose powders in the kits
were found to pose a greater inhalation risk or airborne fibers than the
crayons. None of the products warned users to avoid the dust. In fact,
the instructions for the EduScience Deluxe Forensics Lab Kit instructs
users to: “Put a small amount of dusting powder on the brush, use
the blower to blow on the brush gently and then run the brush softly over
the fingerprinted spot. Use the blower to blow off excess powder on top.”
The asbestos found in these products is present likely as a result of asbestos-contaminated
talc used as a binding agent in the crayons and used as an ingredient
in the powder of the crime scene kits. Asbestos has been found in many
mines alongside talc deposits. Concerns about asbestos contamination of
talc first surfaced in the early 1970s, but federal agencies have failed
to enact rules to ensure that talc used in consumer and industrial products
Because of its widespread use in consumer products, the purity of commercial
talc is a critical issue. It absorbs moisture, oils and odors and is added
to many personal care products and pharmaceuticals. It is the basic ingredient
in many body and food powders. It is also used as a filler for pills and
is dusted on candy and used in the production of olive oil.
CNN contacted importers, distributors and retailers named in the report for
comment. Representatives from Amazon, MII Inc. and Buy-Rite could not
be reached. Spokes-persons for Dollar Tree, Party City, and Toys R Us
have issued statement that their brands take the safety of consumers very
seriously and are further investigating the findings of EWG’s report.
It is believed that children exposed to asbestos are at even greater risk
of developing asbestos related diseases than persons exposed as adults.
At this time, Connecticut is the only state which has imposed an outright
ban of asbestos in children’s’ products.
Read the full report